FULL BLEED: YOU KNOW HIS GLASS IS FULL OF SAND

I know. I’m late for the discourse again. What discourse? Why, world building. Oh, and genre and the usual sorts of stuff. Mostly because Mike Harrison went and won the Booker Prize and lots of people got upset about what he had to say about world building and genre and a lot of this was years and years ago and yeah, hit dogs love to holler, I guess. Folks who write in literary circles hate genre and vice versa. Even if that’s not entirely true, it makes for a pretty convenient set of narrative straw zerglings to burn up. I don’t really want to spend a lot of time on The Genre/Lit Wars other than to observe that those fault lines have been around for a long time. Also that there’s plenty of genre-focused dreck out there and there’s plenty of stuff that’s counted as contemporary literature that’s interminable. Being on one side or the other isn’t absolution, dig?
A lot of what Harrison had to say about world building amounted to “Hey, don’t write up wiki listings of your world and pretend that’s enough. The world is way weirder than all these facts and histories and maybe think about those spaces outside of making up an RPG book.” This is a grotesque simplification but not wrong in spirit. I have to say, of course, that I agree with Mr. Harrison as to this approach. There’s an awful lot of contemporary fantasy that focuses on things that really should be in the background. The story isn’t the catalog of neat magical items with elaborate histories or recitations of dynastic progression.
Unless the point of things is just to establish a setting with maybe some narratives behind it. Unless you’re writing an RPG setting, which, to be fair, you may be called on to do something like that. But that’s not really a narrative fiction. That’s a place for a story to happen in. And sure, some of the history of the world might come into play for your story, maybe just the suggestion of broad strokes is enough. What really matters is what exactly is the story about? And when you can answer that question at least nominally, then you know what you need to know. Is the story about a particular magic item and how it warps the lives of those around it? Then maybe a little history is good to have. Or maybe you just know that it likes to mess with people or slowly absorb their souls or that it has its own agenda for the shape of the political world. Those could happen.
But if you’re writing a story about a group of adventurers adventuring around, maybe you only need a whispered legend or two about a mad wizard creating an armlet in which was bound a demon. Don’t need to go into detail as to how it was forged and the litany of spells used to bind this, of all the thousand demons of Pandemonium, into this piece of jewelry. Don’t need to know about the rarity of the metals or how to smelt two materials with different melting points and etc etc etc. You need to decide the level on which the story is going to operate. Only you get to do that. Just that my feeling is there’s a level settled on which is easier to write because it’s more like a history than a narrative. Or it’s more like a how-to on making swords or whatever it is that you’ve done the research for and by the Maker you are going to show all that research on the page and please don’t. We as the reader needs to know there’s a thing of power and what the pursuit of that power does with the characters. Not necessarily to. Some of them may survive intact. Some may be shattered by where their greed leads them. Some who thought they sought power instead learn that what they sought was security, safety.
And maybe you just need to know that there’s a weird tower with unearthly guardians and at the top of the uppermost floor is an object of power that your hapless heroes have been pressed into seeking and/or will use to upset the balance of power in the region. Story is sometimes hard. There are times it feels easier to dig into details and larger construction slash illustration of the wonders of the world that you’re setting the work in.
I’m not saying writing this stuff is avoiding the harder work of narrative fiction, or that researching is a procrastination tool. It isn’t, necessarily, but it sure can be. Just like overthinking the swirling motivations of your characters before they hit the page. Or writing long blog posts about worldbui—
Hey. Just you hold up a minute.
There’s also the school of thought that if you just put enough words on the page, you can absolutely, completely, wholly transfer the contents of the writing mind into the reader. You, the writer, can describe things so that there can be no misinterpretation. That the distance between what you intended and what the reader pulls from the work is shrunk so small that it effectively doesn’t exist. This, of course, is a lie. But it won’t stop writers from trying it.
You’re better off understanding that your work is one thing to you and you can hope it evokes the same emotions and feelings and head-pictures in the reader as it does for you. You can hope it. But the distance will always be there. Sometimes it’ll be vast. I suggest you get used to it. That’s how it is.
But if you go into things knowing this, you can write with this in mind. You can be evocative and use the actual language of metaphor and simile, play with the words and understand they’re more like a scrying pool than 100% exact representation. You have freedom that folks who go into things saying “I’ve gotta nail down every detail, or at least enough of them so the reader can’t stray from my vision.” Maybe straying from the vision is in some ways the point. Open the work up. Let it breathe. Or I guess you can corset it as tightly as those laces will go, flesh binding and reddening then paling in constriction. But by god, you’ll get that story 100% unscathed into the reader and they won’t be able to make any wrong moves. You’re the man now, dog.
I’m writing a series of books under the umbrella title/setting Hazeland. Maybe you’ve heard me talk about it. They’re all set in mostly very real places that you could fly to, were you so inclined. Sure, the time period is gone, but why let that stop you. And maybe my prose passes along some sense of the place. Maybe some of it is even mostly accurate. But more likely is that I’m using the prose to evoke an impression of a setting. It’s like listening to the Cocteau Twins, particularly the early records. You can hear that there’s lyrics, but they shimmered and bent in such a way that they’re more instrument than direct content. Now, I can’t do what Liz Fraser and Robin Guthrie and Simon Raymonde were doing instrumentally on the page, not directly, but I can reach for something like it. It might not be 100% distinct, but it leaves room for the listener to engage and maybe fill pieces out. It lets them co-write it, should they feel brave enough (though they’re always co-writing, whether they embrace that or not.)
And, to be honest, it lets the story move along more quickly. Things can happen when you as the reader are not parked in long tracts of description and detail heaped upon detail so that the picture of the main character in your head is ready for folks to just draw up and post on Tumblr. But then I’m a guy who is reading something and there’s… nice enough prose describing a thing or a scene unfolding but it keeps going and going and going and I already had enough of a picture of what was going on. I didn’t need more, and it’s really not helping. I’m looking at it and thinking “all this can’t be equally important, so maybe just stick with the salient points and move on.” I’m a stinker, I guess.
I will say, one thing that going all full bore on worldbuilding does is makes for more wiki entries. Maybe that’s the aim. I don’t know. Maybe people are writing for memeability. Or maybe they’re writing just so that they can have the right lists of tropes and story items in their ads. I don’t pretend to understand anymore. I just want to write what I want to write. Which may be in some cases, under-writing according to some. Maybe.
Okay, enough of this. I started work on You’ll Murder Forever a couple weeks ago. Almost sixty pages in and the book has surprised me a few times already. I’m sure it will more. No outline survives the drafting process. The book has to write itself. Hoping to have around a hundred before Thanksgiving, and if not by then by the time my family and I take a trip in early December. Would be nice to have the story preliminaries on the page and out of the way before that happened.
Catch you folks on the flip side.








































